you might not be emerging if:
Inigo Montoya: You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means
you might not be emerging if:
-you think or act as if numbers are important
-you are sure you know what the term "pastor" means
-structure / authority are assumed (important / critical)
-your experience of worship is, in practice, quite narrow
-your future has a dependency on a building or buildings
-preaching / a message, sans discussion, is standard fare
-finances play a (perhaps) "undue" role in decision making
-systems / programs are primarily utilized to address issues
-scripture is normally dissected or predigested before ingested
-*doing* kingdom work is valued more than *being* the kingdom
-you've yet to critique the economic metaphor used to describe salvation
-you read, write or employ systematic methodologies of how to do church
-meetings/services are timed to sub-minute intervals, for efficiencies sake
-being cool / vibey / edgy (and not uncool) is somehow key to the kingdom
-dialogue, particularly negative feedback, is avoided - rather than welcomed
-mythological truth has not regained is rightful place alongside factual truth
-time at a divinity school is considered more useful than time at a monastery
-administrative announcements are allowed to disturb the flow of the service
-the terms "music" and "worship" can be substituted without loss of meaning
-your website architecture mirrors corporate america (mission, vision, values)
-you can point to a senior pastor / figure / person / personality in your community
-you believe society or people-in-general consider spirituality inherently irrelivant
-service elements are added without thought to their role in the holistic experience
-emerging church jargon appears on your website - e.g. 'emerging' or 'postmodern'
-you don't give a second thought to employing marketing techniques for your church
-unity is considered important, rather than a (negative) signal of (artificial) conformity
-your resume / credentials / accomplishments / title, appear prominently or are "relevant"
-you fail to see the irony in propagating "emerging-church" products via christian industry
-you talk, lecture, write books about the emerging church without being one in a community
-growing hearts (i.e. for loving God / loving others) is given less attention than growing heads
-what the central speaker has to share is generally the point - rather than the ensuing dialogue
you might not be emerging if:
-you think or act as if numbers are important
-you are sure you know what the term "pastor" means
-structure / authority are assumed (important / critical)
-your experience of worship is, in practice, quite narrow
-your future has a dependency on a building or buildings
-preaching / a message, sans discussion, is standard fare
-finances play a (perhaps) "undue" role in decision making
-systems / programs are primarily utilized to address issues
-scripture is normally dissected or predigested before ingested
-*doing* kingdom work is valued more than *being* the kingdom
-you've yet to critique the economic metaphor used to describe salvation
-you read, write or employ systematic methodologies of how to do church
-meetings/services are timed to sub-minute intervals, for efficiencies sake
-being cool / vibey / edgy (and not uncool) is somehow key to the kingdom
-dialogue, particularly negative feedback, is avoided - rather than welcomed
-mythological truth has not regained is rightful place alongside factual truth
-time at a divinity school is considered more useful than time at a monastery
-administrative announcements are allowed to disturb the flow of the service
-the terms "music" and "worship" can be substituted without loss of meaning
-your website architecture mirrors corporate america (mission, vision, values)
-you can point to a senior pastor / figure / person / personality in your community
-you believe society or people-in-general consider spirituality inherently irrelivant
-service elements are added without thought to their role in the holistic experience
-emerging church jargon appears on your website - e.g. 'emerging' or 'postmodern'
-you don't give a second thought to employing marketing techniques for your church
-unity is considered important, rather than a (negative) signal of (artificial) conformity
-your resume / credentials / accomplishments / title, appear prominently or are "relevant"
-you fail to see the irony in propagating "emerging-church" products via christian industry
-you talk, lecture, write books about the emerging church without being one in a community
-growing hearts (i.e. for loving God / loving others) is given less attention than growing heads
-what the central speaker has to share is generally the point - rather than the ensuing dialogue
you have yet to deconstruct church
and experience an organic emergence
of something unique to your community
and experience an organic emergence
of something unique to your community


10 Comments:
Nicely done Pete...
Ooh, some of them thar words might be fightin' words to some folks. :-) Rather provocative. That's quite a list. Good stuff...but I wonder, might someone react to it by saying, "Oh crap, I really, really want to be emerging - I'd better fix numbers 5, 11, 15, and 22." Perhaps "You think 'being emerging' is an end unto itself" should be added to the list. (I'm not claiming that you yourself think this.)
Nice work!
In addition, I think some of those things might describe me, and it's INCONCEIVABLE that I might not be emerging. ;-)
"You think 'being emerging' is an end unto itself"
EXCELLENT point mike. added.
... these thoughts were developed and recycled from within the experience of my community. and as mike's comment illustrates, the best ones didn't come from me...
Really, really liked this. Can I paste it (or can YOU paste it) onto the Emergent Africa site?
This is a very helpfull list. thanks.
You might not be emerging if...
...you think a test can tell you whether you are emerging or not.
Nice list, but must be taken with a pinch of salt. The moment we pigeonhole 'what it is to be emergent' we may be in trouble.
This list isn’t especially remarkable… to create one, just consider every formula and assumption in the modern church – that’s your list! :-)
By definition, an emerging phenomena produces an unexpected result... so while it is theoretically possible that emergent behavior could produce a phenomena identical to one generated through, say, hierarchal structures and systematic thinking, it's highly improbable for that to happen. additionally, those who understand emerging phenomena wouldn’t try to predict the outcome... because those outcomes are unexpected.
this list is not about what emergent thinking IS – it’s to point out what emergent thinking, in all probability, ISNT...
The emerging church is real. The need for it is legitimate. The misunderstandings are just as real. So I’m simply trying to ask the question: to those who chase after the fad portion that is the emerging church – and to those who chase after those who chase after the fad; and I’m trying to say, first don’t chase fads, and second don’t accept cheap substitutes.
Do your homework(!) Deconstruct until you’re back at the beginning. No stone is sacred or should be left unturned!
Thanks for the comment at my blog. You have some good stuff in here.
another nice list..
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home